Andy Farrell is a man with some huge calls to make ahead of the British and Irish Lions tour (Image: Getty)
Andy Farrell knows what it takes to win in Australia. Now, he has to pick the men to do it again.
The newly appointed British & Irish Lions head coach was there in 2013 as Warren Gatland’s defence masterminded a bruising, high-intensity series win over the Wallabies.
He was there again in 2017 when the Lions defied the odds to draw with the All Blacks. But this time, it’s his call.
With Farrell at the helm for the 2025 tour, the battle for the No.7 jersey will be one of the most intriguing selection dilemmas. The Lions have always boasted elite opensides, from Sam Warburton to Richard Hill.
But with no outright frontrunner this time, Farrell must decide between a breakdown specialist, an all-action carrier, or a defensive workhorse.
So, who fits the bill? Here’s a look at the leading contenders.
Josh van der Flier (Ireland)
The former World Player of the Year is bound to be one of the favourites. If Farrell wants familiarity and proven quality, Van der Flier is the obvious choice.
The Irish flanker has been at the heart of Ireland’s recent dominance, combining relentless tackling with sharp breakdown work and an underrated carrying game.
Van der Flier was integral to Ireland’s Grand Slam success under Farrell, and with his experience in the system, he starts as the leading contender.
Ben Earl has the ability to break the gain line, support in attack, and operate at high intensity (Image: Getty)
Tommy Reffell (Wales)
Reffell is one of the best jackals in the game and fits the profile of a classic openside. While Farrell has worked very little with him, the Welshman’s performances for Leicester Tigers and his country have made him impossible to ignore.
If Farrell wants someone to disrupt Australia’s possession and to slow down their ball, Reffell could be his man.
Ben Earl (England)
Earl isn’t a traditional No.7, but his ability to break the gain line, support in attack, and operate at high intensity makes him a strong contender. Farrell has shown a preference for mobile, multi-skilled back-rowers, and Earl’s versatility could give him an edge.
The biggest question? Does Farrell see him as an openside or a better fit at No.8.
Rory Darge (Scotland)
Darge has all the attributes of a modern openside – strong over the ball, quick across the park, and capable of linking play. He’s been Scotland’s standout back-rower when fit, and Farrell will be watching his Six Nations performances closely.
His biggest challenge is proving he belongs ahead of more established names.
Sam Underhill (England)
Underhill was a Lions bolter in 2021 before injuries derailed his progress. If he can return to his best, he offers something unique – a defensive juggernaut who can shut down Australia’s attacking threats.
Farrell values physicality, and if Underhill finds form, he could be back in the mix.
The favourite?
Right now, Van der Flier is the clear frontrunner. His experience, leadership, and all-round ability make him the safest bet, especially given his established relationship with Farrell.
Having been a cornerstone of Ireland’s recent success, he offers consistency at the highest level – something that will be invaluable on a short, high-pressure tour. If Farrell wants reliability and a player who knows his system inside out, Van der Flier is the obvious choice.
However, Farrell’s selection style has never been rigid – if he prioritises a breakdown specialist who can disrupt Australia’s quick ball, then Reffell or Darge could stake a serious claim. In a Test series where turnovers could be decisive, their ability to win penalties and slow the opposition ball might appeal.
Then there’s Earl, who brings a different skill set. If the coach leans towards a high-tempo, attacking game plan, Earl’s ability to carry, link play, and provide explosive moments could see him leap ahead.